By Gabriel Francisco Leonardos
November 22, 2016
IP Licensing In Brazil: Brazilian Antitrust Watchdog Reviews Its Rules On Agreements Subject To Prior Approval
It will come into force next Thursday (November 24, 2016) a new resolution issued by CADE (Conselho Administrativo de Defesa Econômica), the Brazilian antitrust authority, that redefines the rules for the submission of “associative contracts” for prior approval.
According to the Brazilian Antitrust Law, once other legal premises are met,
such as annual revenue standards, “associative contracts” must be previously
notified to and approved by CADE before being performed by the parties.
Despite that fact, the 2011 Antitrust Act does not clarify the meaning of
“associative contracts”, which were only defined in 2014 by CADE's
Resolution no 10. This resolution helped to eliminate the former legal
uncertainty on which kinds of commercial agreements had to be submitted to
CADE – a doubt that used to reach intellectual property licensing agreements
– but it had also stablished some confusing criteria, such as different market
share minimum standards and the existence of exclusivity provisions.
The new resolution confirms the conception of “associative contracts” as
those (a) whose term are equal to or exceeds two years and (b) features risk
or revenue sharing between the parties for a common economic endeavor. On
the other hand, the new rule restricts its scope to horizontal cooperation
agreements (where the parties are direct competitors) in the relevant market,
thus removing vertical cooperation agreements (where the parties stand at
different levels of the same market chain) from its range.
The rule according to which any agreement whose term is under two years
must be submitted to CADE upon its renewal remains in force.
Although the new resolution intends to make the criteria simpler, some
questions persist. Since the majority of vertical cooperation agreements does
not have implications on competition, the exclusion of them will certainly
reduce the number of agreements submitted to CADE. Nevertheless, whether
Intellectual Property agreements between competitors fall within the criteria
of common economic enterprise setting forth risk or revenue sharing has to
be studied on a case-by-case basis.
Hence, it is advisable to reassess the background of every agreement made
with competitors that were not sent to CADE and that will complete two years
in force, after which, to be on the safe side, those that could potentially
meet the new standard shall be send to CADE's scrutiny in order to become
enforceable.
The penalties in Brazil for the noncompliance with the antitrust legislation
vary according to the gravity of the conduct. Among other, the law sets forth
the following sanctions: nullity of the association contract, prohibition to
contract with the Public Administration for at least five years, minimum
penalty of 60 thousand BRL and a possible penalty of 0.1% to 20% of the
annual gross revenue of the infringer.
In order to have more information please feel free to contact us, whether in
written or by phone, directly to your usual contact within our office or to
rafael.aguillar@kasznarleonardos.com.
Back
Share:
Last by Gabriel Francisco Leonardos
November 4, 2024
Three partners have been recognized as Leading Partners by Legal 500
We are honored to announce that our partners Elisabeth Kasznar Fekete, Gabriel Leonardos, and Rafael Lacaz Amaral have been recognized as Leading … Three partners have been recognized as Leading Partners by Legal 500
October 25, 2024
Kasznar Leonardos partners are selected as Global Leaders by IAM
We are honored to announce that three of our partners have been included in the prestigious IAM Global Leaders 2025 list! Gabriel … Kasznar Leonardos partners are selected as Global Leaders by IAM
October 8, 2024
Kasznar Leonardos will participate in the AIPPI World Congress 2024
We are pleased to announce that our partners Gabriel Leonardos, João Luis Vianna, and Maria Pia Guerra will participate in the AIPPI … Kasznar Leonardos will participate in the AIPPI World Congress 2024